Aug 24, 2016
The Unpredictable Individual Health Insurance Market
by Mark Farrah Associates
In February 2016, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)
reported that 12.7 million consumers had enrolled in Marketplace plans following
the open enrollment period. Subsequently in March, health insurers reported
providing individual, non-group coverage for 20.2 million people. These updates
indicate that 63% of individual medical members were enrolled through the
Marketplace yet some carriers have announced plans to withdraw from exchanges
next year. About 37% of this segment represents covered lives enrolled in
off-exchange plans; currently an estimated 7.5 million. Many insurers are
turning more attention to off-exchange membership, as they opt out of exchanges
and focus on selling to people who do not qualify for premium subsidies.
Critics of Obamacare have recently ramped up reporting on program weaknesses
and failures and several insurers have indicated their public exchange business
is unsustainable. Advocates continue to defend the long term merits of the
program, suggesting time and patience will pay off as inconsistencies are
resolved and the enrollment base matures. The future of the Marketplace and how
individual health insurance options will trend is anything but predictable.
This brief provides a timely look at recent market developments with
state-by-state membership comparisons and competitor insights.
Setting the Stage: Key Provisions and Outcomes
The individual health insurance market has always been somewhat volatile,
posing greater risks for carriers than other segments. Before Obamacare was
implemented, insurers complied with mandates, medical underwriting standards and
community rating which varied state by state as insurance regulators set the
requirements. One of the most controversial individual market debates prior to
the enactment of the ACA (Affordable Care Act) was on the topic of pre-existing
conditions. In the majority of states, regulations were such that insurers
could deny people coverage based on perceived health risk and ultimate
healthcare cost.
As of January 1, 2014, the ACA prohibited insurers from imposing pre-existing
condition exclusions, giving health plan members access to necessary care from
their first day of coverage. The ACA requires insurance companies to guarantee
issue health plans to any applicant, regardless of health status, and imposes
rating restrictions limiting how much insurers can vary premiums based on an
individual's health status. Individual health plans, both on and off exchange,
now must include the 10 essential health benefits, a package of health care
services deemed to meet minimum coverage requirements.
Another ACA provision that has been met with controversy is known as the
Individual Mandate. Effective since 2014, individuals are required to have
health insurance or pay a penalty for noncompliance. Following an outcry of
appeals that the mandate was unconstitutional, the Supreme Court upheld the law
in June 2012, ruling in favor of the mandate. Those who do not comply must pay
an annual fee when they file their annual tax return. The annual fee for not
having insurance in 2016 is $695 per adult and $347.50 per child (up to $2,085
for a family), or 2.5% of total household income above the tax return filing
threshold given filing status – whichever is greater.
One more key provision of particular interest to insurers was the
implementation of the 3Rs - - risk adjustment, reinsurance and risk corridors.
These programs were designed to balance market uncertainty and promote healthy
competition in the early years of Obamacare. Though this is a rather simplistic
explanation, the idea was to offset risks as insurers grew membership and
learned how to appropriately price coverage.
Fast forward to 2016, more than three years into the Marketplace, and
stakeholders are withdrawing from the exchanges and litigating with the
government over 3Rs payments. A recent Health Affairs Blog report provides a
helpful summary of the 3Rs controversy and litigation.
Key takeaways from the Health Affairs Blog report:
- Unexpected difficulties surrounding the 3Rs have damaged the ACA-reformed
insurance markets. Several insurers, including UnitedHealth and Humana, lost
hundreds of millions of dollars that they expected to have repaid. Some have
chosen to leave ACA markets in 2017.
- While insurers and regulators are still negotiating 2017 rates, it is most
likely that rate increases will be significantly higher next year than any
other year since the ACA was implemented. Meanwhile, insurers with small
capital reserves—most visibly the co-ops, but others too—are going out of
business.
- Some insurers that were promised relief in the event of large losses are
now suing the federal government due to lack of reimbursement.
- Trouble with the 3Rs has insurers questioning the viability of the
ACA-reformed markets. Based on preliminary analyses, the 2017 exchanges will
have fewer options, larger premium increases, and less generous benefits than
prior years since the ACA marketplaces were implemented in 2014.
Citation: Mike Adelberg and Nicholas Bagley,
Struggling To Stabilize: 3Rs Litigation and The Future of the ACA
Exchanges, Health Affairs Blog, August 1, 2016, http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2016/08/01/struggling-to-stabilize-3rs-litigation-and-the-future-of-the-aca-exchanges/,
Copyright ©2016 Health Affairs by Project HOPE – The People-to-People Health
Foundation, Inc.
Insurers React
Insurers have attributed high medical claims, adverse selection, 3Rs program
challenges, immature risk pools, and under-enrollment of younger, healthier
individuals as factors resulting in significant losses on Marketplace business.
Growing concerns about sustainability have motivated some insurers to pull out
of the exchanges. UnitedHealth was one of the first to announce plans to
downsize exchange participation. In April 2016, officials cited high medical
costs and reported the company will operate in only a handful of exchanges in
2017. Humana followed in June 2016, indicating they too would pull out of many
exchanges after a year of nearly $1 billion in losses. Most recently, in August
2016, Aetna reported it would sharply reduce its participation in the public
Marketplaces next year. Several Blue Cross Blue Shield plans and regional
competitors, e.g. Scott and White Health Plan, have also announced intentions to
scale back.
A new analysis from Avalere suggests that one-third of the United States will
have only one insurer to choose for Marketplace coverage in 2017 - - Experts Predict Sharp Decline in Competition across the ACA
Exchanges.
Still, Marketplace advocates maintain that the ACA is in its formative years
and new companies will enter markets as others exit. Supporting analysts have
expressed that the market will stabilize as insurers have access to better data
to set more accurate prices.
Individual Market Covered Lives
Though it's hard to say what the future holds for the ACA, the following
review of recent performance metrics may help shed some light on the volatile
individual health insurance market. Enrollment in individual, non-group medical
plans totaled 20.2 million as of March 2016, according to financial statements
filed by insurers. No surprise, the largest membership generally resides in the
largest states demographically. It is interesting to note, although Marketplace
reports indicate 4.9 million new members enrolled in 2016, year-over-year total
individual market enrollment actually declined slightly by about 1%. Total
individual market enrollment, based on carrier reports, had been 20.4 million a
year ago in March 2015.
It is important to note that Mark Farrah Associates (MFA) applied year-end
2015 enrollment figures for select carriers not required to report health
enrollment on a quarterly basis and made other adjustments based on market
analysis. Furthermore, individual enrollment may include Medicaid programs,
such as CHIP, as some states include subsidized lines in the individual segment.
These factors may have resulted in moderate understatement or overstatement of
enrollment.
Competitor breakdowns of Marketplace enrollment are not readily available
however the following table presents state by state breakdowns of the total
individual market, separating on-exchange and off-exchange membership. For this
assessment, MFA applied the assumption that the difference between total
individual enrollment reported by carrier and on-exchange, Marketplace
enrollment reported in ASPE (Office of The Assistant Secretary, Health and Human
Services) is reasonably representative of off-exchange membership. This
analysis did not include state by state research to provide local market
insights about exchange positioning nor did the analysts investigate
off-exchange plan options. Nonetheless, the state breakdowns provide an
interesting framework for understanding the greater market opportunity.
Individual Health Enrollment On
and Off Exchange |
State |
March 2016 Total
Individual Enrolled |
February
2016 On-Exchange Enrolled |
Estimated Off-Exchange Enrolled |
AK |
20,686 |
23,029 |
N/A |
AL |
246,287 |
195,055 |
51,232 |
AR |
591,467 |
73,648 |
517,819 |
AZ |
325,507 |
203,066 |
122,441 |
CA |
2,632,316 |
1,575,340 |
1,056,976 |
CO |
353,000 |
150,769 |
202,231 |
CT |
178,825 |
116,019 |
62,806 |
DC |
33,207 |
22,693 |
10,514 |
DE |
43,305 |
28,256 |
15,049 |
FL |
2,223,260 |
1,742,819 |
480,441 |
GA |
976,384 |
587,845 |
388,539 |
HI |
46,694 |
14,564 |
32,130 |
IA |
171,904 |
55,089 |
116,815 |
ID |
138,843 |
101,073 |
37,770 |
IL |
609,056 |
388,179 |
220,877 |
IN |
327,417 |
196,242 |
131,175 |
KS |
259,456 |
101,555 |
157,901 |
KY |
199,590 |
93,666 |
105,924 |
LA |
322,298 |
214,148 |
108,150 |
MA |
344,064 |
213,883 |
130,181 |
MD |
396,479 |
162,177 |
234,302 |
ME |
84,570 |
84,059 |
511 |
MI |
532,581 |
345,813 |
186,768 |
MN |
266,911 |
83,507 |
183,404 |
MO |
373,436 |
290,201 |
83,235 |
MS |
190,159 |
108,672 |
81,487 |
MT |
67,418 |
58,114 |
9,304 |
NC |
740,801 |
613,487 |
127,314 |
ND |
61,176 |
21,604 |
39,572 |
NE |
162,551 |
87,835 |
74,716 |
NH |
84,369 |
55,183 |
29,186 |
NJ |
327,133 |
288,573 |
38,560 |
NM |
101,166 |
54,865 |
46,301 |
NV |
182,982 |
88,145 |
94,837 |
NY |
357,497 |
271,964 |
85,533 |
OH |
426,221 |
243,715 |
182,506 |
OK |
163,478 |
145,329 |
18,149 |
OR |
253,017 |
147,109 |
105,908 |
PA |
957,659 |
439,238 |
518,421 |
RI |
47,004 |
34,670 |
12,334 |
SC |
435,193 |
231,849 |
203,344 |
SD |
73,803 |
25,999 |
47,804 |
TN |
344,763 |
268,867 |
75,896 |
TX |
1,801,126 |
1,306,208 |
494,918 |
UT |
294,392 |
175,637 |
118,755 |
VA |
609,335 |
421,897 |
187,438 |
VT |
32,237 |
29,440 |
2,797 |
WA |
369,067 |
200,691 |
168,376 |
WI |
335,671 |
239,034 |
96,637 |
WV |
48,220 |
37,284 |
10,936 |
WY |
38,832 |
23,770 |
15,062 |
|
20,202,813 |
12,681,874 |
7,520,939 |
Source: Health Coverage Portal™, Mark
Farrah Associates, presenting data from NAIC, CA DMHC, and
HHS-ASPE |
In terms of competition, Anthem, UnitedHealth, Aetna, Health Care Service
Corporation (HCSC), Humana and Kaiser lead the industry in this segment, each
reporting more than a million individual medical covered lives as of
1st quarter 2016.
Brief Insights about Financial Performance
As insurers report losing big money in the individual market, underwriting
gain/loss figures from 2015 statutory financial statements confirm these
accounts are valid. Insurers collectively lost almost $6 billion in the segment
last year. On an aggregate basis, individual business summed to a net loss in
41 states plus the District of Columbia. The state of Texas generated the
largest total deficit, with plans reporting a combined net loss of $717 million.
Combined business in nine less populous states was favorable, driven by net
gains reported by local market leaders. Bear in mind, these performance
indicators include business generated both on and off exchange.
Out of 194 companies that filed the 2015 Supplemental Health Care Exhibit
(SHCE), sixty-nine percent or 133 reported aggregate net losses in the
individual, non-group segment. UnitedHealth, HCSC, Humana, Highmark and
Assurant reported the largest aggregate losses last year. A total of 61
companies reported modest aggregate gains in the segment. Guidewell, the parent
company of Blue Cross Blue Shield affiliates operating in Florida was most
profitable, reporting an aggregate net gain of $149 million for 2015.
It is important to keep in mind the underwriting gain/loss figures reported
in the SHCE are preliminary and reported prior to HHS assessment of the 3Rs and
ACA adjustments.
Looking Forward
The Marketplace shakeout will continue as companies both withdraw and enter
new exchange markets. Meanwhile, insurers are working to firm up rates for 2017
individual plans and gear up for open enrollment beginning November 1, 2016. As
for the future of Obamacare, it seems this is a wait and see proposition. Some
say the program is unsustainable and will collapse. Others believe the program
can learn from its mistakes and secure a solid footing in time. Without a
doubt, outcomes from the upcoming presidential and congressional elections will
strongly influence Obamacare's future. Analysts at Mark Farrah Associates will
continue to monitor the unpredictable individual health insurance market. Stay
tuned.
About Mark Farrah Associates (MFA)
Mark Farrah Associates (MFA) is a leading provider of health plan market data
and analysis tools for the healthcare industry. If your company relies on
accurate assessments of health plan market share and financial performance to
support business planning, we encourage you to contact us to learn more about our products. Our portfolio
includes the Health Coverage Portal™, County Health Coverage™, Health Insurer
Insights™, Medicare Business Online™, Medicare Benefits Analyzer™, and Health
Plans USA™ - - http://www.markfarrah.com/default.aspx/.
Healthcare Business Strategy is a FREE monthly brief that presents analysis
of important issues and developments affecting healthcare business today. If
you aren't on our email distribution list, click here to subscribe now.
Mark Farrah Associates
Phone: 724.338.4100
Web: http://www.markfarrah.com/
How
to Request Permission to Link, Cite or Reprint Information from the Mark Farrah
Associates Web Site
© Copyright 1997-2016. All rights reserved.
Unauthorized use is prohibited. Healthcare Business Strategy™ is the product of
Mark Farrah Associates. No part of this product may be reproduced, in any form
or by any means, including posting in its entirety in blogs or other media
applications, without permission in writing from Mark Farrah Associates - (724)
338-4100.